Is Etsy worth it in 2023?

Are you pondering over the thought of launching an Etsy shop in 2023, or are you an existing shop owner contemplating, ‘Is Etsy still worth it?’ This article is your in-depth exploration into the intriguing Etsy universe, serving as a comprehensive guide that will dissect the advantages and potential disadvantages of Etsy.

Here, we don’t just skim the surface, but we dig deep into the question, ‘What is the disadvantage of Etsy?’ while also shedding light on its strengths. As 2023 unfolds, the question of ‘Is Etsy a good side job?’ is more relevant than ever. So, fasten your seat belts as we embark on a detailed journey scrutinizing the feasibility and worthiness of maintaining or starting an Etsy shop in 2023. Let’s plunge in!

The current state of Etsy

Let’s kick things off by checking in on Etsy’s current status. After all, it’s important to get a good look at the state of play before deciding whether it’s the right time to jump in and invest your time and resources, right?

Etsy has grown and evolved so much over time, and it remains one of the big players when it comes to online marketplaces for handmade and vintage items. But the big question we’re asking today is: ‘Is Etsy still worth it for you?’ Let’s dive in and find out!

1. Etsy’s Growth & Popularity

Etsy’s impressive rise over the years is hard to ignore. In 2022, the platform welcomed almost 90 million buyers and hosted over 5 million active sellers. That’s a whole lot of potential customers and competitors! There’s a lot driving this growth:

  • The rise of conscious consumerism: More and more folks are looking for unique, handmade items that make a statement about who they are and what they value. This trend has pushed demand for artisanal products and sustainable businesses sky-high, and guess where you can find plenty of both? Yep, Etsy!
  • The gig economy and the search for extra income: ‘Is Etsy a good side job?’ – That’s what many people have been asking. The ease of setting up shop on Etsy and the chance to sell to a worldwide audience makes it an attractive option for those looking to supplement their income.
  • Recent global events: When 2019 and 2020 forced us to stay home, we turned to online shopping. Sellers followed suit, with many joining Etsy when their physical stores had to close.

Sure, competition is getting fiercer, but Etsy remains an appealing platform for buyers and sellers alike, thanks to its array of creative, unique, and often customizable items.

2. Recent Changes on Etsy

Etsy hasn’t been resting on its laurels; the platform has rolled out several changes over the years to make user experiences better and to help sellers expand their businesses. Here are some of the latest updates:

  • Improvements to the search algorithm: Etsy keeps tweaking its search algorithm to give buyers more relevant results. While this means sellers need to stay on top of these changes and adapt their listings accordingly, it also promises that the right products get in front of the right people.
  • Introduction of Etsy Ads: ‘Is Etsy still worth it?’ With the roll-out of Etsy Ads, which help sellers promote their products on search results and category pages, the answer could be ‘yes’ for those looking for more visibility.
  • Offsite Ads: Introduced in 2020, this feature promotes sellers’ products on platforms like Google, Facebook, and Pinterest. It can help drive additional sales, but bear in mind that fees apply.
  • Expanded seller tools: Etsy has beefed up its suite of tools designed to help sellers manage their businesses, with improvements to inventory management and better integration with shipping carriers.

The competition might have heated up with these changes, but they also open up opportunities for sellers who know how to make the most of them. Stay updated, adapt, and you could find Etsy is still a fantastic place for your business.

Pros of selling on Etsy

Alright, let’s get down to business and explore the benefits of selling on Etsy, why Etsy is still worth it in 2023, and what makes it such a magnet for sellers globally.

1. Built-in Audience

One of the killer advantages of selling on Etsy is tapping into its vast built-in audience. Millions of buyers are already on the hunt for unique, handmade, vintage, and digital items on Etsy. The platform makes it reasonably effortless to showcase your creations to potential customers. Plus, Etsy’s reputation as a trustworthy, well-established marketplace boosts buyer confidence, leading to higher conversion rates.

Capitalizing on Etsy’s popularity could mean saving on marketing efforts and costs. Think about it – drawing customers to a website, earning their trust, and finally nudging them to convert isn’t a cakewalk. You might need to shell out a hefty amount on ads to raise awareness about your brand, and that could take some time to kick in.

2. User-friendly Interface

Another feather in Etsy’s cap is its user-friendly interface, ideal for sellers setting up their shops, listing items, and managing their businesses. If you’re wondering how to succeed on Etsy in 2023, especially with little to no experience in e-commerce or web design, Etsy’s simplicity is your best friend. Comparatively, setting up an Etsy shop is way simpler than creating your own website. No need to fret about web hosting, coding, or designing a site from scratch.

With built-in tools for inventory management, order tracking, and customer communication, staying organized and responsive to customer needs is a breeze.

3. Easy Payments and Shipping Integration

When it comes to handling payments and shipping, Etsy has simplified the process. With multiple payment options for buyers, such as credit cards, PayPal, and Etsy gift cards, and a shipping integration feature that allows you to print shipping labels directly from the platform. Making money on Etsy in 2023 is as straightforward as it gets.

4. Seller Support and Community

As part of Etsy’s seller community, you’ll have access to a treasure trove of resources. This includes the Etsy Seller Handbook, forums, support teams, and more. You’ll be a part of a community of like-minded creative entrepreneurs, always ready to share advice and experiences. This network can be invaluable for navigating challenges, learning, and feeling more connected to the entrepreneurial world.

5. Branding Opportunities

Etsy allows sellers to customize their shop’s appearance, creating a unique and cohesive brand identity. This personal touch can help you stand out from the competition and build a loyal customer base. From customizing your shop banner and logo to crafting a compelling shop story, Etsy provides the tools you need to express your brand’s personality and attract your target audience. By establishing a strong brand identity, you can create an emotional connection with your customers, leading to increased customer loyalty and repeat purchases. Additionally, Etsy’s built-in options for shop policies, FAQ sections, and item descriptions allow you to clearly communicate your brand’s values and unique selling points.

6. Marketing Tools and Analytics

Etsy also provides sellers with various marketing tools and analytics to help promote their products and understand their business performance. With features like Etsy Ads and Offsite Ads, you can increase your shop’s visibility and reach potential customers who may not have found you otherwise. To make things even better, Etsy’s analytics dashboard offers valuable insights into your shop’s performance, such as views, favorites, and sales data, allowing you to make informed decisions about your marketing and product strategies.

7. Social Media Integration

Etsy makes it easy to integrate your shop with popular social media platforms, like Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, and Twitter. This integration allows you to promote your products and reach a broader audience by leveraging the power of social media. Etsy’s social media integration allows you to share your listings and reviews to drive traffic and sales to your Etsy shop. By using social media channels, you can further enhance your brand’s online presence and engage with potential customers in a more personal and interactive way.

8. SEO Benefits

One of the lesser-known benefits of selling on Etsy is the platform’s search engine optimization (SEO) capabilities. Etsy has a strong domain authority, which means that your shop and listings can potentially rank higher on search engine results pages (SERPs) than an independent website, especially if you’re new to e-commerce. So if you’re new to e-commerce and wondering ‘is Etsy a good side job in 2023?’ the platform’s SEO capabilities might be a reason to consider ‘yes’ as an answer.”

Cons of selling on Etsy

It’s true that Etsy has a lot going for it, but like all things, it has its fair share of challenges. So, let’s now take a look at the disadvantages of Etsy and the common hurdles you might encounter as a seller.

1. Fees and Commissions

Etsy fees in 2023 is an aspect you’ll want to keep an eye on. The platform charges listing fees, transaction fees, payment processing fees, and if you opt for ads, extra costs for Etsy Ads or offsite ads. These expenses can pile up and take a bite out of your profits. So, when pricing your items and calculating potential profit margins, you’ll want to factor these costs in.

2. Competition

With millions of active sellers, competition on Etsy is fierce. Standing out from the crowd can be challenging, especially in popular niches though it’s always possible. You’ll need to invest time and effort into marketing your products, optimizing your listings, and offering exceptional customer service to succeed on the platform. Additionally, the competitive nature of the platform may require you to continuously adapt and innovate your product offerings to stay ahead of the curve.

3. Limited Control Over Your Shop

One of the cons of selling on Etsy is the limited control you have over your shop’s appearance and functionality compared to running your own standalone website. While Etsy offers customization options for your shop, you’re still limited by the platform’s rules and guidelines. This means you have less control over your shop’s look and features compared to running your own independent website. On top of that, you’re subject to Etsy’s policies, which can change at any time, potentially affecting your business operations and revenue.

4. Algorithm Changes

As I said earlier, Etsy frequently updates its search algorithm, which can impact your shop’s visibility and sales. Adapting to these changes can be time-consuming and frustrating, but it’s essential for maintaining your shop’s success. Keeping up with algorithm changes may require you to regularly revise your SEO strategies, listing descriptions, and tags to ensure that your products remain visible to potential buyers.

5. Intellectual Property Issues

Selling on a platform like Etsy can sometimes expose you to intellectual property disputes, such as copyright or trademark infringements. This may occur if your product designs are too similar to those of other sellers or well-known brands. Navigating these issues can be complex and time-consuming, and in some cases, may lead to your listings being taken down or your shop being suspended so you do want to be very careful with that.

6. Potential for Oversaturation

As the platform continues to grow in popularity, there’s a risk of oversaturation in certain categories or niches. This means that as more sellers enter the market, it may become increasingly difficult to differentiate your products and maintain strong sales. In some cases, oversaturation can lead to a decrease in overall demand and a reduction in the perceived value of your products. Now, whilst this is a very real problem, it’s always possible to niche down, even in saturated markets. For example, instead of going with mugs, I would suggest focusing on a specific sub niche such as book lovers mugs or gamer mugs.

7. Reliance on a Third-Party Platform

Another downside of Etsy is that you’re relying on a third-party platform. While this does have benefits, it also means you’re subject to their rules and any potential platform-wide issues. Relying solely on Etsy can limit your opportunities to develop your own brand presence and customer relationships outside of the platform.

8. Customer Expectations

As Etsy is known for its unique items, customers often have high expectations for product quality and customer service. Meeting and exceeding these expectations can be demanding and time-consuming, particularly for small or solo sellers. Maintaining a high level of customer satisfaction is essential for your shop’s success on Etsy, but it may require a significant investment of time and effort in responding to inquiries, customizing orders, and handling potential issues like returns or refunds.

9. Limited Marketing Features

While Etsy does provide some marketing tools and features, they may not be as comprehensive or customizable as those available through an independent website or other e-commerce platforms. For instance, you may have limited control over email marketing campaigns, customer data collection, or creating highly targeted promotions for specific customer segments. This can restrict your ability to implement more advanced marketing strategies and grow your customer base.

10. Scaling Challenges

And as your business grows, you may encounter challenges in scaling your Etsy shop to accommodate increased demand. This can include managing a larger inventory, fulfilling more orders, or expanding your product line. While Etsy does offer some tools for inventory management and order fulfillment, they may not be as robust or scalable as those available through other e-commerce platforms or independent websites. As a result, sellers may need to invest in additional software or external solutions to effectively scale their businesses.

Making Etsy work for you

So, given the Etsy pros and cons 2023, you may wonder, “Is Etsy worth it in 2023?” The answer depends on your unique situation, aspirations, and expectations. However, there are ways to harness the potential of Etsy, ensuring you have the best shot at success. The more energy you invest in your shop, the greater the rewards you’ll likely reap.

1. Optimize Your Listings

To improve visibility and sales, it’s crucial to optimize your listings with effective keywords, high-quality images, and compelling product descriptions. This not only helps you rank higher in search results but also attracts potential customers to your shop. Regularly review and update your listings to ensure they remain relevant and appealing to your target audience.

2. Offer Exceptional Customer Service

Providing top-notch customer service can set you apart from the competition and lead to positive reviews, repeat customers, and word-of-mouth referrals. Respond to customer inquiries promptly, personalize your packaging, and address any issues professionally. Going the extra mile to make your customers happy can significantly impact your shop’s reputation and success.

3. Consider Diversifying Your Sales Channels

To minimize risk and maximize profit, consider comparing Etsy vs other online marketplaces in 2023 and selling on multiple platforms or even creating your own website alongside your Etsy shop. This can help you reach new audiences and give you more control over your business. By diversifying your sales channels, you can reduce your dependency on Etsy and ensure a more stable income stream.

The advice I always give to Etsy sellers is start with Etsy but don’t rely on it and do your best to create revenue on your own platform as quickly as possible. That usually means using the revenue from Etsy to promote your own website until it works by itself.

4. Invest in Your Brand

Developing a strong brand identity can set you apart from competitors and attract loyal customers. Invest in professional photography, create a cohesive visual identity, and develop a unique brand voice to create a memorable shopping experience for your customers.

5. Monitor and Analyze Your Performance

Frequent monitoring and analysis of your shop’s performance are key Etsy selling tips 2023. Use Etsy’s built-in analytics tools and Google Analytics to gain insights into your shop’s traffic, conversion rates, and customer behavior. With this data, you can make informed decisions to optimize your shop and grow your business.Regularly track and analyze your shop’s performance to identify areas for improvement and capitalize on successful strategies. Use Etsy’s built-in analytics tools as well as Google Analytics to gain insights into your shop’s traffic, conversion rates, and customer behavior. By monitoring and analyzing your performance, you can make data-driven decisions to optimize your shop and grow your business.

6. Offer a Unique Value Proposition

To stand out from the competition, it’s essential to offer a unique value proposition. Focus on creating high-quality, distinctive products that cater to a specific niche or target audience. Emphasize what sets your products apart, whether it’s the materials you use, your design process, or the story behind your creations.

7. Leverage Etsy’s Advertising and Promotion Tools

Make the most of Etsy’s advertising and promotion tools to increase your shop’s visibility and attract more customers. Experiment with Etsy Ads to find the most effective strategies for your business. Be sure to track the results of your ad campaigns to optimize your budget and maximize your return on investment.

8. Continuously Improve Your Skills

To succeed on Etsy in 2023, it’s essential to continually upgrade your skills in product creation, marketing, photography, and customer service. Invest in online courses, attend workshops, or join industry-specific groups to stay updated with the latest techniques and best practices. The more skilled you are in various aspects of running your Etsy shop, the better positioned you’ll be to grow and succeed.

So, is selling on Etsy profitable in 2023? After assessing the pros and cons and exploring strategies to make Etsy work for you, it seems the platform still presents ample opportunities for success. Despite the challenges and disadvantages, I believe the benefits and growth potential outweigh the cons.

Starting an Etsy shop requires dedication, perseverance, and constant improvement. As long as you’re willing to put in the effort to optimize your shop, craft unique and high-quality products, and market your brand effectively, you can create your own Etsy success story.

To all new and aspiring Etsy sellers out there, don’t let the challenges discourage you. With the right mindset and strategies, you can turn your passion into a thriving business on Etsy. Remember, success doesn’t happen overnight, but with hard work and persistence, you can achieve your goals and build a profitable shop in 2023 and beyond.

If you found this article useful and you’re looking for even more tips and advice to take your Etsy shop to the next level, download your FREE Etsy guide to success to help you get consistent sales in your Etsy shop below.

It’s 10 pages full of information that you need to know if you’re trying to have a successful Etsy shop.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top